Electing S Corp Status for your LLC

Published: 10/24/2015 12:27:46 PM

Since we usually get a number of questions regarding the impacts of an LLC electing to be taxed as an S Corporation we thought it would be beneficial to address some of these issues.

An LLC is a legal structure, not a tax structure. For tax purposes an LLC is “diregarded”. Basically meaning that we pretend as if it does not exist. So, an LLC with two or more owners, it will be classified as a partnership for tax purposes, and if it has only one owner, the entity will be disregarded for tax purposes and report as a sole proprietorship. However, the LLC may elect to be taxed as either and S Corporation or a C Corporation.

The regulations allow an LLC that would be classified as a partnership or a disregarded entity under the default rules to elect to be taxed like a corporation. Corporate status is achieved by filing Form 8832, Entity Classification Election, electing to treat the entity as an “association.” An association is treated as a corporation for federal income tax purposes. Once the LLC elects association status, its owner(s) may also choose to have it taxed as an S corporation. To simplify the election process in such cases, it is not necessary to file both Form 8832 to elect association status and Form 2553 to elect S corporation status. The Regulations allow a single election to be made on Form 2553. A timely filed Form 2553 will constitute a deemed filing of Form 8832. This deemed association election is effective only if the electing entity meets all of the requirements to be an S corporation. Form 2553 also is not effective if the entity fails to qualify as an S corporation as of the election date.

While not required of the LLC form, most LLC entities begin their life with an operating agreement prepared by a business attorney. As most LLC entities default to partnership tax treatment, a standard form operating agreement will contain language addressing the federal income tax issues that one typically sees with a partnership. A variety of provisions in a standard form operating agreement must be reviewed before an S election is made for an LLC. Many of these typical LLC operating agreement provisions are not permitted if the entity is to be taxed as an S corporation.

S corporations are subject to specific eligibility rules under the tax laws, including the requirement that the corporation have a single class of stock (SCOS). Generally, a second class of stock will exist if shareholder equity rights differ with respect to distribution rights and liquidation rights. This does not apply to voting rights. Also, all allocations of profit and loss must follow share ownership. The operating agreement, must be examined to determine if there are differences in liquidation or distribution rights. The standard LLC operating agreement, not designed for an entity taxed as an S corporation, will have no reference to “stock” ownership. Priorities on cash distributions, or provisions that require distributions on liquidation of a member’s interest to follow capital accounts, would also violate the SCOS requirement. These concerns must be addressed with modifications to the operating agreement.

The most significant modification to the standard operating agreement would be to provide that no member has priority over any other member with respect to distributions, either during operations or upon liquidation of a member’s interest. This would require deletion of any references to capital accounts.

It will also be necessary to eliminate the standard references to allocations for pre-contribution or pre-admittance. Any preference or guaranteed returns for capital will also need to be eliminated, with all distributions following only member ownership interests. Of course, it is also necessary to define ownership interests, which will replace the stock ownership of a corporation. Members may define ownership in such a way that it is the economic equivalent of stock ownership, forming the basis for satisfying the SCOS requirement. It is common for LLC operating agreements to provide for capital calls, with remedies available when one (or more) member fails to timely make a capital call. Similar provisions may be incorporated into an agreement of an entity that plans to be an S corporation, with the remedy being changes in the defined ownership interests of members who default on calls, forcing others to make up for the defaulting member. The revised ownership interests would continue to form the basis for allocations of profit and loss and for post-change distribution rights, as is required by the SCOS requirement. Similarly, a buy-sell or redemption agreement incorporated into the operating agreement (or a side agreement) needs to be tested for compliance with safe harbors regulations.

As is the case with an S corporation formed under state corporate law, members of an LLC electing S status may be paid different amounts for the services they provide to the entity and may receive payments for property leased to the entity or money loaned to the entity. The standard approaches used to protect against violations of a second class of stock with such arrangements should be considered when designing the capital structure of the entity.

The agreement may also include language often found in S corporation shareholder agreements to prevent a termination of the election, such as restricting transfers to ineligible shareholders, permitting an examination of any trusts for compliance with the eligible shareholder requirement, and perhaps a general statement that the members understand that the entity is to be taxed under subchapter S and will act in accordance with that intent.

The Regulations state that a timely election under Subchapter S is a deemed association election, provided that, at the effective date of the election, the entity meets all other requirements to be an S corporation. The Code further notes that if the eligible entity’s S election is not timely and valid, the default classification rules will apply to the entity unless IRS provides late S corporation election relief or inadvertent invalid election relief. The default status would then be a partnership if the LLC has two or more members, or a disregarded entity if it has only one owner.

For those taxpayers following the simplified election procedure, the (defective) S election would have been filed using only Form 2553. However, Regulations and the instructions to Form 8832, require it to be attached to the entity’s return for the year that the association election is to be effective. This copy need not be signed. Failure to attach Form 8832 does not invalidate the election, but may subject the non-filer to penalties.

It is not clear if one should attach a “dummy” Form 8832 to the entity’s initial Form 1120S when it was never originally filed. The regulations seem to open the door to this approach by stating that the copy of Form 8832 attached to the return need not be signed. If Form 8832 was actually filed, a copy of that original filing would include the signatures required for that form to constitute an effective association election. If, however, Form 8832 was not filed due to use of the simplified filing procedures, it would not be possible to file a copy of it, but one could prepare a Form 8832, without signature (the signature consents to the elective status indicated on Form 8832), to attach to the return. Presumably a non-signed form would not (independent of Form 2553) be effective as an entity association election. Thus, even if the LLC owners attached an unsigned dummy Form 8832 to the initial Form 1120S filing, that form alone should not be effective to establish association status for the entity. This issue would be significant because the failure to qualify as an S corporation would make the entity a C corporation if the Form 8832 attached to the initial return was deemed to be an association election. The status should otherwise default to a partnership.

The most obvious approach to use when electing S corporation status for an LLC is to review the operating agreement and make suggestions to change any provisions inconsistent with subchapter S. However, understanding that the obvious approach is either not always obvious or is not always followed, you need to consider the fallback treatment of an entity that has filed a defective Form 2553.

If a Form 8832 was never filed in any manner, including as an unsigned attachment to the initial Form 1120S, the entity classification would, as previously stated, default to the classification rules. If the only Form 8832 filed was as an attachment to Form 1120S, it could be reasonably argued that, even if the form was signed, the election would not be effective in the manner filed. At worst, it could be effective only prospectively because it must be filed within the first 75 days of the tax year for which it is to be effective. Late election relief may be available, but only on the taxpayer’s request, which would not be done when no association treatment was desired. If unsigned, which would likely be the case for a Form 8832 prepared solely as an attachment, it would be difficult for the IRS to argue successfully that the entity had elected association status. The default classification status would then apply to the LLC. Many advisors do not file a Form 8832 with the entity’s return when the form was not previously filed to elect association status affirmatively. For those who choose to attach a Form 8832 to the original Form 1120S, the form should not be signed (which is permitted by the regulations).

It is clear that flow-through entities are the most popular form of business entity in the U.S., but what is less clear is whether the S corporation or the partnership form is best suited for a particular business venture. Without addressing the “proper” choice, this article focuses on the mechanics of treating an entity formed as a state law LLC as an S corporation for federal tax purposes and ways to avoid potential traps. These include needed revisions to a standard operating agreement as well as compliance with the election mechanics. If a taxpayer undertakes the election mechanics without first modifying the operating agreement, the resulting entity may be a partnership or a C corporation. How the election is made may offer a safeguard in the event it is later discovered that an eligibility failure occurred.

If you have any questions regarding the election to an S Corporation or the right tax structure for your business, please do not hesitate to contact us.

Contact Us

All Posts

Job Opening

3/18/2019 10:36:19 PM

Year-end tax planning moves for individuals and businesses

11/3/2017 5:54:06 PM

7 Factors that Influence Your Home Mortgage Interest Rate

10/30/2017 3:53:23 PM

The Most Overlooked Tax Deduction by Real Estate Owners

10/30/2017 3:52:08 PM

Tax Strategy: The broad principles of tax reform

10/30/2017 3:43:09 PM

6 Things To Know About Your Side Hustle And Taxes

7/19/2017 10:10:40 PM

Payroll Mistakes? Get ready to lose employees...

6/11/2017 8:00:43 PM

IRAs and tax-efficient charitable giving: What you need to know

4/2/2017 1:26:57 AM

Three Benefits of Maximizing Your Relationship with Accountants

2/9/2017 7:37:51 AM

IRS Offers Tips on Choosing a Tax Preparer

2/9/2017 7:25:18 AM

23 Tax Deductions You Can't Afford to Overlook

12/23/2016 5:22:28 AM

BREAKING NEWS: Judge Suspends Overtime Rule Set for Dec. 1st

11/24/2016 7:58:14 AM

Six Tax Planning Strategies To Prepare For A Trump Presidency

11/21/2016 10:07:33 PM

10 Year-End Tax-Planning Tips for Individuals

11/5/2016 4:53:25 PM

7 Things Most Millennials Don't Know About Preparing For Retirement

10/29/2016 6:39:40 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Follow the 1040

10/5/2016 4:53:42 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Delaying IRA Distributions

9/8/2016 11:46:41 AM

5 Reasons Your Small Business Needs an Accountant

8/25/2016 11:27:35 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Better Roth Conversions

8/24/2016 12:04:43 AM

Nine compelling benefits of a Roth IRA

8/16/2016 7:53:22 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Stretch an IRA and Delay Paying Uncle Sam

8/9/2016 6:49:17 PM

Back-to-School Tax Tips

8/9/2016 6:47:47 PM

Tax Tips for Newlyweds

7/28/2016 11:15:46 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Gray Divorce, and More

7/28/2016 11:15:30 AM

The Best Method for Paying Off Each Kind of Loan

7/20/2016 12:20:42 PM

Why you may want to take IRA money at 59½

7/19/2016 3:44:47 PM

Tax Savings from a Home Office

7/19/2016 3:09:47 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Earn with Owing Tax

7/19/2016 2:51:21 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Picking the Best Shelter

7/11/2016 7:28:02 PM

2016 Tax Series: 8 Sweet Fringe Benefits

7/8/2016 11:20:59 AM

How to Save $10,000 in 6 Months

7/7/2016 10:17:54 PM

Changes affecting qualified retirement plans

7/3/2016 6:23:30 PM

IRS Expands Electric Vehicle Tax Credit to 30 Cars, Including 3 Porsche Models

6/23/2016 7:42:10 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Favorable Yields for Risk-Takers

6/23/2016 6:45:43 PM

How Investors Can Salvage Tax Losses With the Wash Sale Rule

6/14/2016 10:48:08 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: 8 Tips for Clients Moving Overseas

6/14/2016 12:32:17 AM

6 Quick Tax Tips for Students Starting a Summer Job

6/12/2016 1:56:55 PM

Top 10 Tax Deductions for Active Traders

6/12/2016 1:55:55 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: A Better Graduation Gift

5/30/2016 12:51:50 AM

5 Steps Small Businesses Must Take to Prepare for New Overtime Pay Rules

5/30/2016 12:49:44 AM

Attention Employers: Prepare Yourselves for the New Overtime Law

5/21/2016 12:47:22 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Limits of Like-Kind Exchanges

5/10/2016 12:09:18 PM

Charitable Tax Trick For Big And Little Donors

5/10/2016 12:06:43 PM

Understanding Distributions from Traditional IRAs and Taxes at Death

5/10/2016 12:00:52 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Picking a Retirement Portfolio

5/3/2016 3:37:19 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Extra Taxes on Boomers?

4/29/2016 1:54:08 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Deducting Investment Manager Fees

4/29/2016 1:51:39 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Boosting Millennials' Returns

4/18/2016 5:46:18 PM

How to Plan a Successful Business Exit

4/18/2016 5:43:10 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Payoff from Donating IRA Assets

4/6/2016 1:57:40 PM

Valuation: Start Treating Your Business As An Investment!

4/3/2016 4:13:59 PM

Balance Funding an IRA with Other Financial Goals

3/9/2016 12:48:39 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Roth Conversion Do-Overs Can Pay Off

3/9/2016 12:33:36 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Minimizing the Tax Bite in Taxable Accounts

3/2/2016 8:12:42 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Tax Advantages of Old Age

2/24/2016 10:06:01 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Max Out Benefits for Student Loan Borrowers

2/24/2016 10:03:51 AM

11 Ways to Avoid the IRA Early Withdrawal Penalty

2/19/2016 1:02:58 AM

Difference Between Cash Flow and Accounting Income

2/17/2016 11:04:17 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: No Receipts? No Problem!

2/1/2016 11:29:53 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: A Millennial Marriage Tax?

1/28/2016 4:27:32 PM

5 Outrageous, But Legitimate, Income Tax Deductions

1/26/2016 2:08:42 PM

6 Retirement-Planning Mistakes to Avoid

1/24/2016 9:05:22 PM

Major Business Tax Changes for 2016

1/24/2016 7:54:09 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: More Investment Returns, Fewer Taxes

1/19/2016 9:36:22 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Genius Tax Write-Offs

1/11/2016 9:15:59 PM

Why Tax Planning Should Be a Year-Round Priority

1/11/2016 7:59:06 PM

10 Things You Absolutely Need To Know About Taxes

1/8/2016 8:36:35 AM

Lessons From the Tax Court: Medical Exception For IRAs

12/30/2015 4:28:04 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Doing Good Deeds for Savings

12/21/2015 12:42:07 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Capital Gains Can COST Clients

12/16/2015 12:30:14 AM

Small Business Owners Need to Focus More on Tax Planning

12/16/2015 12:11:13 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Hitting the Gifting Limit

12/9/2015 12:48:33 PM

Timing Payments Around the Close of the Year

12/9/2015 12:39:02 PM

Year-End Tax Tips for Business Owners

12/5/2015 11:20:58 AM

6 Tips for Saving for Retirement in 2016

11/30/2015 10:00:37 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Harvesting Energy Investments

11/24/2015 12:02:38 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Take the Bite Out of 401(k) Conversions

11/16/2015 9:10:50 AM

Don’t Miss These Year-End Tax-Saving Maneuvers

11/14/2015 6:33:42 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Reducing the Tax Hit on Investments

11/5/2015 2:02:35 PM

10 Year-End Tax-Planning Tips Your Clients Shouldn't Ignore

10/30/2015 9:58:04 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Avoiding Taxes on Home Sale

10/26/2015 12:39:54 PM

Electing S Corp Status for your LLC

10/24/2015 12:27:46 PM

CPA Estate Planning Tips

10/22/2015 1:10:49 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Best Way to Make IRA Withdrawals

10/20/2015 11:23:16 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Offset Gains and Income; Homeowner Tricks; HSAs; and Shadow Banking

10/14/2015 4:08:52 PM

Tax Planning Businesses Can Do Before Year End

10/14/2015 3:51:51 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Trimming Taxes on Investments

10/8/2015 12:19:44 PM

Should You Delay Marriage to Save Tax Dollars?

10/8/2015 12:08:21 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: MUNIs on the Rise

10/8/2015 11:34:25 AM

7 Tax Tricks for Homeowners

10/8/2015 11:33:54 AM

11 Tips for Investors in Their 30s and 40s

10/8/2015 11:33:25 AM

How Landlords Can Write off Rental Property Losses

10/8/2015 11:01:28 AM

Income Tax Reminders for Owners of Vacation Homes

9/29/2015 2:19:03 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Hiring Your Kids

9/25/2015 12:22:05 PM

Take An Extra Year To Pay Taxes Thanks To This Generous Accounting Rule

9/25/2015 12:07:05 PM

Teaching Kids to Invest

9/15/2015 9:20:55 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Recouping Client Losses

8/31/2015 11:52:59 AM

401(k) vs Roth IRA: Which is Best?

8/27/2015 5:44:09 PM

Five Ways To Deduct Losses In Financial Markets

8/25/2015 10:24:41 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Minimizing Taxes on Social Security

8/24/2015 3:10:20 PM

LLCs, S Corps & PCs: Choosing a Business Entity

8/21/2015 2:26:10 PM

Why Do Accountants Lose Clients?

8/20/2015 2:50:08 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Inherited IRAs

8/17/2015 4:42:32 PM

How to Deduct Real Estate Losses

8/15/2015 10:44:45 AM

Are You Prepared for the Latest Independent Contractor Crackdown?

8/13/2015 3:36:25 PM

Bonus Depreciation (Sec. 179) and the Repair Regs.

8/12/2015 6:34:29 PM

IRS Summertime Tax Tips

8/5/2015 3:17:12 PM

Stepping Up to Wealth Management

7/30/2015 3:14:51 PM

5 Financial Tips for Newly-Employed Young People

7/30/2015 2:40:28 PM

Majority of Family Businesses Unprepared for Succession

7/22/2015 6:17:48 PM

Baby on Board? 7 Tax Tips for Expectant (and Hoping to be Expectant) Parents

7/20/2015 2:54:36 PM

7 Tax Tips On Vacation Home Rentals

7/17/2015 1:05:56 PM

Why Real Estate Investment Is Your Best Tax Shelter

7/17/2015 9:11:48 AM

Which Employee Fringe Benefits Are Taxable?

7/17/2015 9:05:40 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Deduct Capital Losses the Right Way

7/16/2015 6:19:16 PM

New Tax Penalty on Small Business Health Insurance

7/3/2015 11:46:08 AM

Tax, Estate Planning, Benefits Opportunities After Supreme Court's Same-Sex Marriage Decision

6/30/2015 3:11:07 PM

Summer Camp & College: More Fun, Less Taxing

6/24/2015 3:28:51 PM

S Corps - Surviving an IRS Reasonable Compensation Challenge

6/16/2015 6:51:23 PM

Making the Most of Required Minimum Distributions at Retirement

6/9/2015 5:09:01 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Less Taxing Investments

6/8/2015 3:03:55 PM

Determining how much Medicare tax you may pay on business income

5/30/2015 1:23:05 PM

Business Entity Selection- Audit Risk

5/29/2015 2:26:33 PM

7 Biggest Threats to Your Retirement

5/21/2015 11:28:02 AM

2015 Tax Rates, Deductions, Exemptions, Credits, & More

5/20/2015 6:04:33 PM

Qualified Personal Residence Trusts - Reduce Estate Taxes!

5/15/2015 2:52:12 PM

Tax-Related Investment Strategies

5/12/2015 9:55:49 PM

Tax Considerations for Cancellation-of-Debt Income

5/12/2015 4:33:39 PM

When It's OK to Tap Your IRA

4/30/2015 11:59:22 AM

1031 Exchanges - 10 Things to Know

4/29/2015 6:41:12 PM

15 Ways to Spend a Refund

4/28/2015 8:53:15 PM

Tax Issues with Marijuana

4/28/2015 8:53:00 PM