Tax Strategy: The broad principles of tax reform

Published: 10/30/2017 3:43:09 PM

On Sept. 27, 2017, the Trump administration and Republican congressional leaders issued a nine-page outline on tax reform titled a “Unified Framework for Fixing Our Broken Tax Code.” At the start of the year we were, of course, supposed to have tax reform enacted by September. Instead, we have had a one-page outline followed now by a nine-page outline.

The outline does not provide much more detail than we had before from the administration and Congress, and leaves much still to be worked out in the tax-writing committees of Congress. However, it does provide the areas in which the administration and Republican congressional leaders have so far reached agreement.

Individual provisions

For individuals, there is agreement on three new tax bracket rates of 12, 25 and 35 percent, but no agreement on the income levels to which they will apply. Mention is also made of a possible higher fourth tax rate if necessary to maintain the current progressivity of the Tax Code.

There is agreement on a near doubling of the standard deduction to $24,000 for married filing jointly and $12,000 for single filers, along with eliminating the personal exemption, but for some taxpayers it still appears that the loss of the personal exemption may not be fully offset by the increase in the standard deduction.

There is agreement to increase the Child Tax Credit and its income phase-out limits, but by undetermined amounts. The agreement calls for a new $500 credit for caring for non-child dependents, but it is not clear if this is in place of or in addition to the current dependent care credit.

The only itemized deductions specifically identified for retention are the home mortgage interest deduction and the charitable contribution deduction, with vague references to retaining but simplifying tax breaks for work, higher education and retirement, and even proposing to enhance retirement plan participation and resources available in retirement. It appears by implication that the state and local tax deduction is one of the items on the chopping block, although there appears to be a sufficiently significant block of Republicans from high-tax states in the House that this deduction may be revived in some form. The casualty loss deduction also appears to be on the chopping block at the same time that Congress has passed legislation to enhance the casualty loss deduction for victims of Harvey, Irma and Maria.

The agreement also calls for repeal of the Alternative Minimum Tax, the estate tax, and the generation-skipping transfer tax. There is also a call for more accurate inflation adjustments going forward, which has been generally interpreted to mean smaller inflation adjustments.


Business provisions

Similarly for businesses, there is agreement on a new top corporate tax rate of 20 percent, and there is general language, apparently to appease Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, about promising an effort to look at reducing double taxation of corporate earnings. There is also agreement on a new top tax rate of 25 percent for small businesses conducted as partnerships, S corporations or sole proprietorships, but the agreement only generally promises to try to distinguish business income from personal income without specifying how. The inclusion of sole proprietorships is significant, since some prior proposals did not appear to include them. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin has also talked of generally excluding professional entities where the earnings can be primarily attributable to the labor of individuals. These distinctions would probably contribute to additional Tax Code complexity.

The agreement calls for unlimited expensing of depreciable assets starting on September 27, 2017, the only effective date specified in the outline, but only for five years. There is also a general reference to further enhancements of small-business expensing. The agreement also speaks of a partial limit on net interest deductions, with possible distinctions between corporate and non-corporate taxpayers, without providing any further details.

Only two credits are specifically preserved — the Research & Development Credit and the Low-Income Housing Credit — while the domestic production activities deduction under Code Sec. 199 would be eliminated. The agreement states generally that other business exclusions and deductions may be repealed or restricted, and industry-specific tax breaks will be reviewed to better reflect economic reality and prevent tax avoidance.

The corporate AMT would also be repealed.


International provisions

In the international area, the agreement calls for a territorial tax system. It also calls for an unspecified tax on unrepatriated earnings spread over several years, indicating probably an inability to reach a compromise on the various rates proposed in earlier tax reform versions and also perhaps a desire to maintain flexibility to see what rate might be needed to help pay for the tax cuts.

The agreement also calls for a tax at an unspecified reduced rate to prevent shifting profits to off-shore tax havens. This is a somewhat new concept, probably inserted to replace the House proposal for a border adjustment tax and President Trump’s proposal for tariffs on trading partners viewed as having an unfair trading advantage. How this tax might be structured and applied is still uncertain at this point, but it is unlikely to contribute to tax simplification.


The revenue raisers

As has been the case throughout the tax reform process so far, the tax reform proposals have been much more detailed on the tax cuts than how they will be paid for. This unified framework is no exception to the rule. Aside from the unspecified tax on unrepatriated earnings and the implication that certain unnamed current tax breaks will go away, the unified framework focuses primarily on the good news from tax reform rather than the bad news.

The last effort to put tax reform into serious legislative language was Rep. Dave Camp’s effort in 2014, which was sufficiently detailed to contain provisions that upset just about everyone. Republicans will push to rely on economic growth projections as much as possible as an innocuous way to pay for tax reform without upsetting any constituency, but the Congressional Budget Office seems unlikely to put as much money into that pot as the drafters might hope. They are also no longer talking about a revenue-neutral tax reform bill, but that could also mean only temporary tax cuts to preserve the 51-vote requirement under budget reconciliation, but which also requires no projected deficits beyond the 10-year point. If forced to start specifically identifying other tax breaks that will be eliminated, then the lobbyists will get to work and, as we saw with the Camp tax reform plan and the current proposal to curtail the state and local tax deduction, the legislative process is likely to bog down again.


Summary

The unified framework has advanced tax reform only to the extent of providing more agreement on the easy issues while still leaving the tough issues to be worked out in Congress. The stated goal of the administration is to have tax reform legislation through the House by the end of October, through the Senate by the end of November, and to the president in December. Very few people outside of the administration and Republican congressional leaders think that will happen, except for a possible much-reduced effort to provide some modest rate cuts effective retroactively to the beginning of 2017. Most people expect that the process will bog down as the details start to emerge. The lack of progress from January to now is certainly not a good sign that significant tax reform will happen by year-end.

Treasury Secretary Mnuchin has also expressed a desire that tax reform will, as much as possible, be retroactive to the beginning of 2017. This will be easier for the tax cuts than for any revenue-raisers, especially the elimination of any tax breaks on which taxpayers have been relying during 2017. If tax reform slips to 2018, retroactivity to 2017 will become much more difficult. Year-end tax changes affecting 2017 will still be difficult for the Internal Revenue Service to incorporate in its forms and software and still start the tax filing season on time.

While the administration states that its goal in tax reform is primarily to reduce taxes for the middle class, most analysts seem to be finding it hard to see how the current proposals could achieve that goal. Like health care reform, it may be that Congressional Budget Office projections could help to doom the tax reform effort by peeling away votes from those concerned that those promises are not being kept.

Make an appointment with Complete Financial Services today! "We're not just your accountants, we're your trusted advisors."

Contact Us

Follow us on Facebook for great tax tips!

Source: Accounting Today

All Posts

Job Opening

3/18/2019 10:36:19 PM

Year-end tax planning moves for individuals and businesses

11/3/2017 5:54:06 PM

7 Factors that Influence Your Home Mortgage Interest Rate

10/30/2017 3:53:23 PM

The Most Overlooked Tax Deduction by Real Estate Owners

10/30/2017 3:52:08 PM

Tax Strategy: The broad principles of tax reform

10/30/2017 3:43:09 PM

6 Things To Know About Your Side Hustle And Taxes

7/19/2017 10:10:40 PM

Payroll Mistakes? Get ready to lose employees...

6/11/2017 8:00:43 PM

IRAs and tax-efficient charitable giving: What you need to know

4/2/2017 1:26:57 AM

Three Benefits of Maximizing Your Relationship with Accountants

2/9/2017 7:37:51 AM

IRS Offers Tips on Choosing a Tax Preparer

2/9/2017 7:25:18 AM

23 Tax Deductions You Can't Afford to Overlook

12/23/2016 5:22:28 AM

BREAKING NEWS: Judge Suspends Overtime Rule Set for Dec. 1st

11/24/2016 7:58:14 AM

Six Tax Planning Strategies To Prepare For A Trump Presidency

11/21/2016 10:07:33 PM

10 Year-End Tax-Planning Tips for Individuals

11/5/2016 4:53:25 PM

7 Things Most Millennials Don't Know About Preparing For Retirement

10/29/2016 6:39:40 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Follow the 1040

10/5/2016 4:53:42 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Delaying IRA Distributions

9/8/2016 11:46:41 AM

5 Reasons Your Small Business Needs an Accountant

8/25/2016 11:27:35 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Better Roth Conversions

8/24/2016 12:04:43 AM

Nine compelling benefits of a Roth IRA

8/16/2016 7:53:22 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Stretch an IRA and Delay Paying Uncle Sam

8/9/2016 6:49:17 PM

Back-to-School Tax Tips

8/9/2016 6:47:47 PM

Tax Tips for Newlyweds

7/28/2016 11:15:46 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Gray Divorce, and More

7/28/2016 11:15:30 AM

The Best Method for Paying Off Each Kind of Loan

7/20/2016 12:20:42 PM

Why you may want to take IRA money at 59½

7/19/2016 3:44:47 PM

Tax Savings from a Home Office

7/19/2016 3:09:47 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Earn with Owing Tax

7/19/2016 2:51:21 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Picking the Best Shelter

7/11/2016 7:28:02 PM

2016 Tax Series: 8 Sweet Fringe Benefits

7/8/2016 11:20:59 AM

How to Save $10,000 in 6 Months

7/7/2016 10:17:54 PM

Changes affecting qualified retirement plans

7/3/2016 6:23:30 PM

IRS Expands Electric Vehicle Tax Credit to 30 Cars, Including 3 Porsche Models

6/23/2016 7:42:10 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Favorable Yields for Risk-Takers

6/23/2016 6:45:43 PM

How Investors Can Salvage Tax Losses With the Wash Sale Rule

6/14/2016 10:48:08 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: 8 Tips for Clients Moving Overseas

6/14/2016 12:32:17 AM

6 Quick Tax Tips for Students Starting a Summer Job

6/12/2016 1:56:55 PM

Top 10 Tax Deductions for Active Traders

6/12/2016 1:55:55 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: A Better Graduation Gift

5/30/2016 12:51:50 AM

5 Steps Small Businesses Must Take to Prepare for New Overtime Pay Rules

5/30/2016 12:49:44 AM

Attention Employers: Prepare Yourselves for the New Overtime Law

5/21/2016 12:47:22 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Limits of Like-Kind Exchanges

5/10/2016 12:09:18 PM

Charitable Tax Trick For Big And Little Donors

5/10/2016 12:06:43 PM

Understanding Distributions from Traditional IRAs and Taxes at Death

5/10/2016 12:00:52 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Picking a Retirement Portfolio

5/3/2016 3:37:19 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: Extra Taxes on Boomers?

4/29/2016 1:54:08 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Deducting Investment Manager Fees

4/29/2016 1:51:39 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Boosting Millennials' Returns

4/18/2016 5:46:18 PM

How to Plan a Successful Business Exit

4/18/2016 5:43:10 PM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Payoff from Donating IRA Assets

4/6/2016 1:57:40 PM

Valuation: Start Treating Your Business As An Investment!

4/3/2016 4:13:59 PM

Balance Funding an IRA with Other Financial Goals

3/9/2016 12:48:39 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Roth Conversion Do-Overs Can Pay Off

3/9/2016 12:33:36 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Minimizing the Tax Bite in Taxable Accounts

3/2/2016 8:12:42 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: The Tax Advantages of Old Age

2/24/2016 10:06:01 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Max Out Benefits for Student Loan Borrowers

2/24/2016 10:03:51 AM

11 Ways to Avoid the IRA Early Withdrawal Penalty

2/19/2016 1:02:58 AM

Difference Between Cash Flow and Accounting Income

2/17/2016 11:04:17 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: No Receipts? No Problem!

2/1/2016 11:29:53 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: A Millennial Marriage Tax?

1/28/2016 4:27:32 PM

5 Outrageous, But Legitimate, Income Tax Deductions

1/26/2016 2:08:42 PM

6 Retirement-Planning Mistakes to Avoid

1/24/2016 9:05:22 PM

Major Business Tax Changes for 2016

1/24/2016 7:54:09 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: More Investment Returns, Fewer Taxes

1/19/2016 9:36:22 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Genius Tax Write-Offs

1/11/2016 9:15:59 PM

Why Tax Planning Should Be a Year-Round Priority

1/11/2016 7:59:06 PM

10 Things You Absolutely Need To Know About Taxes

1/8/2016 8:36:35 AM

Lessons From the Tax Court: Medical Exception For IRAs

12/30/2015 4:28:04 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Doing Good Deeds for Savings

12/21/2015 12:42:07 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Capital Gains Can COST Clients

12/16/2015 12:30:14 AM

Small Business Owners Need to Focus More on Tax Planning

12/16/2015 12:11:13 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Hitting the Gifting Limit

12/9/2015 12:48:33 PM

Timing Payments Around the Close of the Year

12/9/2015 12:39:02 PM

Year-End Tax Tips for Business Owners

12/5/2015 11:20:58 AM

6 Tips for Saving for Retirement in 2016

11/30/2015 10:00:37 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Harvesting Energy Investments

11/24/2015 12:02:38 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Take the Bite Out of 401(k) Conversions

11/16/2015 9:10:50 AM

Don’t Miss These Year-End Tax-Saving Maneuvers

11/14/2015 6:33:42 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Reducing the Tax Hit on Investments

11/5/2015 2:02:35 PM

10 Year-End Tax-Planning Tips Your Clients Shouldn't Ignore

10/30/2015 9:58:04 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Avoiding Taxes on Home Sale

10/26/2015 12:39:54 PM

Electing S Corp Status for your LLC

10/24/2015 12:27:46 PM

CPA Estate Planning Tips

10/22/2015 1:10:49 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Best Way to Make IRA Withdrawals

10/20/2015 11:23:16 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Offset Gains and Income; Homeowner Tricks; HSAs; and Shadow Banking

10/14/2015 4:08:52 PM

Tax Planning Businesses Can Do Before Year End

10/14/2015 3:51:51 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Trimming Taxes on Investments

10/8/2015 12:19:44 PM

Should You Delay Marriage to Save Tax Dollars?

10/8/2015 12:08:21 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: MUNIs on the Rise

10/8/2015 11:34:25 AM

7 Tax Tricks for Homeowners

10/8/2015 11:33:54 AM

11 Tips for Investors in Their 30s and 40s

10/8/2015 11:33:25 AM

How Landlords Can Write off Rental Property Losses

10/8/2015 11:01:28 AM

Income Tax Reminders for Owners of Vacation Homes

9/29/2015 2:19:03 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Hiring Your Kids

9/25/2015 12:22:05 PM

Take An Extra Year To Pay Taxes Thanks To This Generous Accounting Rule

9/25/2015 12:07:05 PM

Teaching Kids to Invest

9/15/2015 9:20:55 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Recouping Client Losses

8/31/2015 11:52:59 AM

401(k) vs Roth IRA: Which is Best?

8/27/2015 5:44:09 PM

Five Ways To Deduct Losses In Financial Markets

8/25/2015 10:24:41 AM

Tax Strategies Scan: Minimizing Taxes on Social Security

8/24/2015 3:10:20 PM

LLCs, S Corps & PCs: Choosing a Business Entity

8/21/2015 2:26:10 PM

Why Do Accountants Lose Clients?

8/20/2015 2:50:08 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Inherited IRAs

8/17/2015 4:42:32 PM

How to Deduct Real Estate Losses

8/15/2015 10:44:45 AM

Are You Prepared for the Latest Independent Contractor Crackdown?

8/13/2015 3:36:25 PM

Bonus Depreciation (Sec. 179) and the Repair Regs.

8/12/2015 6:34:29 PM

IRS Summertime Tax Tips

8/5/2015 3:17:12 PM

Stepping Up to Wealth Management

7/30/2015 3:14:51 PM

5 Financial Tips for Newly-Employed Young People

7/30/2015 2:40:28 PM

Majority of Family Businesses Unprepared for Succession

7/22/2015 6:17:48 PM

Baby on Board? 7 Tax Tips for Expectant (and Hoping to be Expectant) Parents

7/20/2015 2:54:36 PM

7 Tax Tips On Vacation Home Rentals

7/17/2015 1:05:56 PM

Why Real Estate Investment Is Your Best Tax Shelter

7/17/2015 9:11:48 AM

Which Employee Fringe Benefits Are Taxable?

7/17/2015 9:05:40 AM

Tax Strategy Scan: Deduct Capital Losses the Right Way

7/16/2015 6:19:16 PM

New Tax Penalty on Small Business Health Insurance

7/3/2015 11:46:08 AM

Tax, Estate Planning, Benefits Opportunities After Supreme Court's Same-Sex Marriage Decision

6/30/2015 3:11:07 PM

Summer Camp & College: More Fun, Less Taxing

6/24/2015 3:28:51 PM

S Corps - Surviving an IRS Reasonable Compensation Challenge

6/16/2015 6:51:23 PM

Making the Most of Required Minimum Distributions at Retirement

6/9/2015 5:09:01 PM

Tax Strategies Scan: Less Taxing Investments

6/8/2015 3:03:55 PM

Determining how much Medicare tax you may pay on business income

5/30/2015 1:23:05 PM

Business Entity Selection- Audit Risk

5/29/2015 2:26:33 PM

7 Biggest Threats to Your Retirement

5/21/2015 11:28:02 AM

2015 Tax Rates, Deductions, Exemptions, Credits, & More

5/20/2015 6:04:33 PM

Qualified Personal Residence Trusts - Reduce Estate Taxes!

5/15/2015 2:52:12 PM

Tax-Related Investment Strategies

5/12/2015 9:55:49 PM

Tax Considerations for Cancellation-of-Debt Income

5/12/2015 4:33:39 PM

When It's OK to Tap Your IRA

4/30/2015 11:59:22 AM

1031 Exchanges - 10 Things to Know

4/29/2015 6:41:12 PM

15 Ways to Spend a Refund

4/28/2015 8:53:15 PM

Tax Issues with Marijuana

4/28/2015 8:53:00 PM